A Court of Mist and Fury (A Court of Thorns and Roses, #2) by Sarah J. Maas
Published by Bloomsbury USA Childrens on May 3, 2016
Genres: young adult/new adult, romance, fantasy, retellings
Amazon | Barnes & Noble | Goodreads | IndieBound
AHHH. I’m so glad I stuck with this series. This book was so good. In fact, so far, it’s the only Fae book I’ve read and enjoyed.
After reading ACOTAR, I was apprehensive about reading ACOMAF. So many people liked the first book, but I didn’t, so if they loved the first book, would I?
I was worried the answer would be no. I didn’t love Tamlin and Feyre as a couple, but I was all right with them by the end of ACOTAR, so, going into ACOMAF I wasn’t sure about Rhysand as a love interest—both because my first impression of him was less than stellar, and because I don’t like change.
Don’t get me wrong: The first 100 pages or so of this book was boring. Feyre is preparing for her wedding to Tamlin (or, more accurately, watching other people prepare for her wedding to Tamlin), and both of them are still processing the trauma they experienced under the mountain—trauma that is driving a wedge between them and making Tamlin overprotective and uncaring. I commend Maas for being willing to show this trauma; characters are people, guys; if they go through something traumatic, it’s not like that trauma just disappears after the traumatic experiences ends. But I was still very uninterested in the story, and I wondered how I would get through 500 more pages of this. For the slightest moment, I doubted I’d finish the book.
But I pushed through, and now I understand why this book is so long. It pulls you in, slowly immersing you in a fascinating, cleverly-developed world full of culture and customs I loved reading about.
This book is an amazing insight into Maas’s Fae culture, and I loved every bit of it. I want to disappear into this world and become Fae, you guys. I would love it. And I can picture my life here, because I can picture the Day and Night courts, Rhys’s house, the cabins, Starfall. I said in my review of ACOTAR that I wanted more world-building, and here, Maas gives it in abundance.
I also loved the slow development of Feyre and Rhys’s relationship, both as friends, and as lovers. I liked how it wasn’t instant attraction, how each of them have burdens they’re struggling to bear and trauma to get over, but how they challenge each other in small ways —and big ones—so one helps the other become a better person.
I loved how Rhys was patient with Feyre, how he never forced her to do what she wasn’t comfortable with and how he trusted her to judge circumstances fairly. He listened to her opinions, respected her needs, and deferred to her for important decisions she needed to make about herself. He respected her and did not try to undermine. He was supportive of her choices, and I loved that. He treated her like a woman, not a girl. It’s a rare sight to see in YA fantasy—not that all male love interests in YA fantasy are actively working to subjugate their female protagonists, but seeing Rhysand instead actively working to help Feyre and others recognize her own power and influence–and honoring that power and influence—was refreshing.
But aside from that, I love Rhys. He’s cocky sometimes, sure, but he’s definitely not the corny bad boy I thought he was when I read ACOTAR. No, Rhys is a man (or, as much a man as a High Fae can be, I guess). He’s a ruler who cares about the safety and wellbeing of his people—a ruler who would made the ultimate sacrifice for his subjects, and, in many ways, already has. And, on top of that, he’s sensitive and caring and merciful, but strong, too. To me, Rhysand is the perfect example of a happy medium for a male love interest somewhere between “I man you woman” and “sobbing pile of gook.” He’s just so well-balanced, and I love how he pushed Feyre to come into her own—without undermining her needs and without dictating who she will become. The level of trust there is, again, so refreshing and wonderful to read. (I’ll never stop talking about this, will I?)
Also, Rhysand’s inner circle? I love them. Each member is just wonderful in their own way, all fierce, but all compassionate. I wish I had a group of friends like that—friends just as deadly as they are loyal.
There were a few scenes I felt were excessive in content, and the length to which Maas vilifies Tamlin was a bit much for me, but overall this was a wonderful read. It took some time for the book to grow on me, but once I was in, I was slowly submerged in something vivid and engaging and fun. The world-building, character relationships, and even the plot were all constructed so thoroughly that this book didn’t feel (more or less) 700 pages long. I almost wish there was more of it.